This post was originally published on December 20, 2024, and updated on February 18, 2025.

Energization—the process of connecting electrification projects like clean heating and cooling systems or electric vehicle (EV) charging equipment to the grid—is vital to decarbonizing the economy. Transitioning buildings and vehicles from fossil fuel energy sources to electric power reduces carbon emissions (though the extent of emissions reductions depends on the power sources that supply a utility’s electric power). 

Despite having “the most aggressive set of truck electrification goals in the country,” EV charging projects in California are facing significant delays in energization due to lengthy grid capacity updates. Electric truck charging stations in particular are having to wait “years–or even up to decades…to get the electricity they need.”1

This September, the California Public Utilities Commission released a decision that set target energization timelines for the state’s three major utilities, Pacific Gas & Electric Company, San Diego Gas & Electric Company, and Southern California Edison Company. IREC has been an active participant in this California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) docket. While establishing energization timelines is an initial step in the right direction, it isn’t enough to speed up energization and meet the state’s ambitious transportation electrification goals. The CPUC needs to set more aggressive timelines for utilities to energize clean energy projects. 

What could this look like? In this article, we share IREC’s vision for a collaborative working group to 1) better define the energization process; and 2) design a framework for assessing the pace of energization, which can inform future timeline updates. (Read our previous blog post for more details on what Decision 24-09-020 requires from utilities, timelines for different types of energization projects, and context on California’s clean energy goals and legislation.)

What’s at Stake: Meeting Regulatory Mandates and Higher Clean Energy Demands

The timely transition to clean transportation depends on how quickly states accommodate the rapidly increasing need for EV chargers. This means the CPUC must set regulations that require utilities to complete energization projects and larger system upgrades faster and more efficiently. 

At a practical level, two California regulations that aim to reduce emissions from cars and trucks (the Advanced Clean Trucks (ACT) and Advanced Clean Cars II (ACC II)2 will put millions more zero-emission vehicles on the road in the coming years, and heighten demand for EV charging capacity. The ACT rule requires an increasing fraction of medium- and heavy-duty vehicle (MHDV) sales to be zero-emission vehicles by 2035, with different sales timelines for different classes of vehicles. The ACC II rule requires 100% of new passenger vehicles delivered for sale in California to meet a zero-emission standard by 2035. (Read more about these rules in our previous blog post.) 

All these zero-emission vehicles will need chargers to power them. 

To keep up with such electrification demands, the California Air Resources Board estimates that utilities will need to energize 300 to 600 direct current fast chargers every week to power these vehicles. To appreciate how significant an increase this is from historical rates of deployment, it is worth noting that a 2018 Executive Order set a goal of 7 years to install just 10,000 fast chargers. 

The bottom line: customers won’t buy zero-emission vehicles if they are uncertain they can charge them, and, unfortunately, the CPUC’s September decision does not sufficiently accelerate energization processes to ensure that is the case.

California Can’t Accelerate Energization with “Business-as-Usual” Data

California is a leader and model for clean energy transition. To date, 17 states have adopted all or part of California’s low-emission and zero-emission vehicle regulations,3 and these states are likely to encounter similar challenges in energization timelines. If California regulators can establish strong systems for accelerating energization, they can maximize the national impact of these standards. 

However, the timelines established in September’s decision relied on data the utilities provided on their average energization project timelines—timelines that California legislators had already determined were far too long. 

Moreover, the decision allows for energization timelines for projects that require new or upgraded equipment on the project site (such as distribution or service line extensions to a home, building, or electric vehicle infrastructure like a new charging station) to be paused when it triggers work beyond the project site.

For clarification, the decision states that when an energization project triggers a new or upgraded circuit or substation (called an “upstream capacity project”), that additional work is an entirely new project with its own timeline. Undermining the very call to accelerate energization, the decision allows a new or upgraded circuit to take as many as 1.9 years to complete and a new substation to take 8.9 years to complete before the original project timeline is resumed.

While upstream capacity projects are more complex, IREC asserts that they are part of the energization process that the California legislature has determined must have “target energization time periods”4—essentially, project lengths that utilities can be held accountable for. IREC’s analysis of the legislation concludes that no legal exception exists that permits failing to set maximum targets for any energization project. 

IREC recommended that the CPUC seek to improve these averages by setting far lower maximum targets. As stated in our opening comments on the proposed decisions, “this approach squarely contravenes SB 410’s requirement to ‘improve the speed’ of energization.” IREC provided these cautions to the Commission in opening comments and had hoped to see revisions in the final decision that better aligned with legislative mandates and a clearer drive to meet clean energy goals.

IREC Urgently Recommends a Working Group for Phase 2

California can’t afford these protracted energization project timelines and delays to impede progress toward its clean energy goals and demands.

In IREC’s opening comments on the proposed decision, we recommended a working group comprised of parties with a vested interest in reliable and affordable clean energy. The CPUC’s final decision acknowledged that a working group may be considered for Phase 2 of these proceedings, and we continue to advocate for this need. 

Based on IREC’s experience working with utilities and customers to understand project barriers and develop creative solutions, we recommend a working group whose technical, policy, and legal expertise can be leveraged, and we advise that they begin by first examining the energization process. Such a review is necessary because utilities do not currently have a clearly defined process for receiving and completing energization projects. (Traditional interconnection between the grid and distributed energy resources is governed by standard procedures and timelines, and we advocate for modeling energization processes after these.) 

The working group can then streamline the process by removing redundancies, discovering timesaving opportunities like parallel and concurrent work, and developing other kinds of efficiencies.

Once the energization process is well defined and optimized, we can align steps with timelines aimed at completing the work faster. Timelines cannot be an effective acceleration tool without a defined process to apply them to.

A Bigger Picture: Tracking the Pace of Energization Across California

IREC also recommends that the CPUC track the pace at which energization must occur to meet California’s decarbonization goals. This means not looking only at individual project timelines, but at the bigger picture of how many new electrification projects are coming online over time. In short, tracking the pace of energization would clarify if California is on track with energizing as many projects as needed to meet the state’s goals. 

Analyzing the pace of energization can then reveal whether individual timelines need to be revised, or whether another intervention is needed. IREC proposed that a working group take up this effort in Phase 2 of the proceeding, and the CPUC expressed some interest in establishing a working group to explore that topic. (Subscribe to our blog to get notified as soon as our next article, a deep dive on the pace of electric vehicle energization, is available.)

Ultimately, IREC urges the CPUC and California’s utilities to approach Phase 2 of this energization timeline effort with care and a focus on clear processes, meaningful timelines, and continuous improvement. State-wide carbon neutrality by 2045 is more than an ambition, it’s a promise to California residents and everyone who is watching and following the state’s example. If this next phase results in streamlined energization processes and a process to ensure the pace of energization remains on track, it will have positive impacts not only in California but also far beyond the state’s borders.

Footnotes

  1. St. John, Jeff. “California’s Backlog Grid is Holding Up Its Electric Truck Dreams.” Canary Media, 23 September 2024. ↩︎
  2. A third rule, Advanced Clean Fleets (ACF) was another regulation aimed at reducing fleet emissions. However, on January 13, 2025, the California Air Resources Board (CARB) withdrew its request for a waiver under the Clean Air Act (Section 209) to implement the Advanced Clean Fleets rule. Essentially, ACF emissions standards can no longer be adopted by the state. ↩︎
  3. “Advanced Clean Cars II, Latest Update–Amendments to Advanced Clean Cars II.” California Air Resources Board. ↩︎
  4. Read more about Senate Bill 410 and Assembly Bill 50. ↩︎